Disclaimer

Notice

The rules of the Bar Council of India do not permit advertisement or solicitation by Advocates in any form or manner. These websites, viz. www.vsmlegal.in and www.vsm.legal, and the contents thereof are merely for informational purposes and not in the nature of solicitation or an advertisement.

Any matter, information or content posted by VSM LEGAL ASSOCIATES LLP [VSM Legal] on this website shall not be construed as legal advice. VSM Legal takes no liability for consequences of any action taken by you relying on the matter, information or content posted on this website.

By entering this website, you confirm and acknowledge that you have voluntarily sought the information relating to and/or posted by VSM Legal and that there has been no solicitation, advertisement or inducement by VSM Legal, its partners or its members.

Leave this site

VSM VSM LEGAL

Citations · Law · Negotiable Instruments Act

Whether the court should dismiss a complaint for the dishonour of cheque if cheque amount is more than amount due?

15/05/2020

However, the learned Trial Court found contradiction in the number of cartons in the complaint as well as in the statement of the appellant. It was found that the cheque amount is more than the amount allegedly due on the date when cheque was presented, therefore, the complaint was dismissed. It held that there are three different versions as to the number of apple cartons, therefore, the alleged amount would have been less than the amount claimed by the complainant. Once the agent of the respondent has admitted the settlement of due amount and in absence of any other evidence the Trial Court or the High Court could not dismiss the complaint only on account of discrepancies in the determination of the amount due or oral evidence in the amount due when the written document crystalizes the amount due for which the cheque was issued.

  1. The accused has failed to lead any evidence to rebut the statutory presumption, a finding returned by both the Trial Court and the High Court. Both Courts not only erred in law but also committed perversity when the due amount is said to be disputed only on account of discrepancy in the cartons, packing material or the rate to determine the total liability as if the appellant was proving his debt before the Civil Court. Therefore, it is presumed that the cheques in question were drawn for consideration and the holder of the cheques i.e., the appellant received the same in discharge of an existing debt. The onus, thereafter, shifts on the accused appellant to establish a probable defence so as to rebut such a presumption, which onus has not been discharged by the respondent.
  2. Learned counsel for the respondent has referred to the judgment reported in M. S. Narayana Menon v. State of Kerala 9 (2006) 6 SCC 39 that evidence adduced by the complainant can be relied upon to rebut
    the presumption of consideration. However, said judgment has no
    applicability to the facts of the present case as the Trial Court has found that the presumption is not rebutted but still the Trial Court dismissed the complaint for the reason that the appellant has failed to prove the amount mentioned in the cheque as due amount. Once the cheque is proved to be issued it carries statutory presumption of consideration. Then the onus is on the respondent to disprove the presumption at which the respondenthas miserably failed.
  3. In Kumar Exports evidence to rebut the presumption was led and accepted by the Court. In these circumstances, it was held that the burden shifts back to the complainant and the presumption
    under the Act will not again come to his rescue. However, in the present case, the presumption of consideration has not been rebutted by the respondent even on the basis of the evidence laid by the appellant. The difference in the number of cartons supplied or the rate charged is not relevant when the accounts were settled in writing to rebut the presumption of consideration of issuance of a cheque.

???? REPORTABLE

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF INDIA

CRIMINAL APPELLATE JURISDICTION

CRIMINAL APPEAL NO. 1545 OF 2019

UTTAM RAM Vs DEVINDER SINGH HUDAN

HEMANT GUPTA, J.

Dated:OCTOBER 17, 2019

This note summarises a reported decision for information only. It is not legal advice and is not a substitute for reading the judgment.